Old School
A large issue within the DJing and producing world is the lack of on stage mixing. If you do not know what i'm talking about with the whole mixing thing ill give you a run down. Mixing is taking two different songs and blasting them together creatively to create something that sounds awesome. Check this clip out for a visual on how awesome it is.
This is amazing. There is no doubt about that. How he just creates the music and beats on the spot and you see it all unfold in front of your eyes. Beautiful. But you also need to notice that the records he is using he did not create. He is using someone else's' work for his DJing. There is so much more that goes on behind the scenes to create a song that this kind of DJ will use.
What does old school have going for it? It's creative and fun to watch as it's happening. Wasn't it exciting to watch the DJ in the video above? It was a lot more interesting than a DJ who sits up above his tracks and does literally nothing. Also there is more to your name. More skill attributed to your name. It's awesome to have a scratch artist at a club playing banger hits and doing creative mixes live. It has a great feel to it. But to everything there is a bad side. VERY easy to screw up a mix. You are live and you are bound to make a mistake while doing quick scratching and mixing. And the thing is, everyone notices too. All the attention is mostly on you so if something falls through, they know.
New School
The "New School" DJs are less about live preforming and more about creating original content. So to the new schoolers it's more about what they create then about how the preform their creations. Here are the inter workings behind a big song in the electronic genre.
This is but a taste to what these DJ do behind the computer. Even before mastering the song, in which I'm not going to go into. Everything needs to sound correct with every element in the right place and flowing continuously throughout the entire track.
New school is amazing in the way they can make music sound the way they want. They cannot do the same thing in old school mixing. You can only change so much live in a old school set. Also there is no limit for time to produce a track. there really is no way to screw up as bad as old school DJs can screw up. Perfection is a virtue within the new school DJ's. But the negative side to that is there is a lot of dirt going around about the skill of new school DJ's posing as old school DJ's. And it's true, the skill of a new school DJ is in the production of the track, not the live mixing. So consequently on stage the new school artists do not have the skill as live old school DJ's. Giving them a bad reputation live.
Old School vs. New School
Now here is the issue that is coming up over all DJ realms, new school DJs don't do anything and here is a funny way to present their argument.
Even though I fully support new school DJs, I have to agree. They've already created their song exactly how they want it to sound so there is no reason to go and change it and potentially ruining it in front of hundreds of thousands of fans. Personally I think this is a just a battle of different values. the old school values their performance on stage and how they can manipulate the sounds live. On the flip side, old school values how hard they slaved in the lab to create this amazing song. There is no "This one is better than that one!" argument because they aren't even on the same playing field. They are awesome in different ways. Yes, I will agree that new school acts like old school but can you blame them. And honestly they are not doing nothing up there. They are manipulating the different frequencies to make the track sound the best it can at the venue and even though they are not making the amazing sounds right on the spot they are mixing from one song to the next while beat matching or other practices in the DJ world.
Mixing has changed throughout the ages with new technology and new personalities. There is no direct right or wrong in this situation it is a matter of opinion and setting for all issues. Either way they, new and old school DJs, deserve the highest respect as musicians and should be revered as such.
PLUR,
Taren McCullough